EST. 1985DINE IN • CARRY OUT • DELIVERYCATERING FOR ALL OCCASIONS
Middletown, NY · Since 1985

A slice of the old
neighborhood. Authentic. Homestyle. Italian.

Forty years on Route 211, still cooking fresh from our home to yours. You want the best, we've got the best.

Dine In Carry Out Delivery Catering Always Fresh
Homemade Bread Hand-Tossed Pizza Authentic Italian Kitchen Est. 1985 Family Catering Fresh Daily Homemade Bread Hand-Tossed Pizza Authentic Italian Kitchen Est. 1985 Family Catering Fresh Daily
Our Story

Forty years of cooking fresh from our home to yours.

Alfonso's was established in 1985, and since that day we provide our customers with our authentic Italian style of cooking. At Alfonso's, we make sure you leave happy and not hungry.

"We offer the best quality of food you can find in this area. Not only is it cooked to perfection, it's cooked fresh from our home to yours."

All food is prepared in our authentic homestyle Italian kitchen — subs on homemade bread, pasta made to order, pizza the way it should be. No shortcuts, no tricks. Just good food, the old way.

Established
1985
835 NY-211 · Middletown, NY
Deals & Specials

Small rituals. Big flavor.

House Favorite

Pizza by the Sea

Our signature specialty pie, loaded. A classic house pick.

$28.00
Lunch Deal

Personal 10" Combo

Personal 10" pizza, 4 garlic knots, and a can of soda. Choose any toppings, sauce & cheese.

Mix & Match
Party Size

Party Strombolis

Regular, sausage, chicken, veggie, eggplant, or pizza rolls — feeds the whole room.

By Order
Seasonal

Holiday Catering Menu

Big trays for the family gathering. Home or office, any occasion.

Call to Plan
Catering & Gallery

For your home, or your office.

Catering available for all occasions. Trays, strombolis, pans of baked pasta — we handle the feeding. You handle the party.

Find Us

On Route 211, right where we've always been.

Call or Visit

845-692-5993 alfonsospizza85@yahoo.com
835 NY-211
Middletown, NY 10941

Call 845-692-5993 Get Directions

Hours

  • Monday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Friday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Sunday12 Noon – 10 PM

Kitchen stays open all day — perfect for an early dinner, late slice, or anything in between. Call ahead for large orders and catering.